Introduction
Patients have a legal and ethical right to decide what happens to their own body. Valid consent is required before examination, treatment, referral, or transport for treatment — from routine personal care through to major interventions.
The law requires informed consent before treatment, except where an emergency makes obtaining it impracticable, or where the law says otherwise (for example, certain powers under mental health legislation). Treating a patient without valid consent, outside those exceptions, is unlawful — it can amount to a civil or criminal assault and expose the clinician to litigation and regulatory sanction.
Refusal to consent is common especially in the pre-hospital environment. A refusal does not end a clinician’s duty of care: you may still have legal and professional responsibilities to offer further intervention, particularly where there is a risk to life, while respecting the patient’s right to decide
Principals of Consent
Consent may be explicit (spoken or written) or implied by the patient’s behaviour — for example, offering an arm for a blood pressure cuff. Patients must be supported to be involved in decisions about their own care wherever they are able.
On each occasion before examining, treating or caring for a patient, you need their consent unless they lack capacity to give it or a genuine emergency makes seeking it impracticable. For well-informed patients with chronic conditions, this is often better thought of as joint decision-making than a single request for permission.
Never assume a patient consents simply because they called for help. Discuss the proposed course of action, reach agreement, and record it. Patients can withdraw consent at any time, and reasonable adjustments, such as interpreters, visual aids, plain language, should be made so they can understand what is proposed.
Consent is a continuing process, not a one-off event. Check it still holds whenever care is handed over, or where a patient’s capacity may fluctuate.
Valid Consent
Capacity
Patients must be 16 years or older and have the mental capacity to make the decision
Informed
Patients must have been given enough information, including material risks and all reasonable options, in a way they can understand..
Patients must have been given enough information, including material risks and all reasonable options, in a way they can understand..
Voluntary
The Patient must have made their own decision voluntarily and free from pressure or coercion
Free to Refuse
The patient must know they can say no, and a refusal must itself be informed and made with capacity.
Capacity
Adults are presumed in law to have capacity unless it is established otherwise.
.An assessment is needed where there is reason to doubt this — for example, where the patient’s presentation suggests impairment, they have previously lacked capacity for similar decisions, or people who know them raise concerns.
Once capacity is in question, the burden is on the clinician to show, on the balance of probabilities, that the patient lacks capacity for the specific decision at the specific time.
Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific: a patient may have capacity for some decisions but not others.
Assessment must follow the five statutory principles in section 1 of the Mental Capacity Act 2005:
